Skip to content

Navigation breadcrumbs

  1. Home
  2. Press releases
28 March 2019

Response to Court of Protection judgment on the case of Mrs Rushton

Mrs Rushton was diagnosed as being in a persistent vegetative state following a traumatic head injury in December 2015.

Usha Grieve, Director of Partnerships and Information at Compassion in Dying, said:

“This is a tragic and distressing case in which the clearly expressed wishes of Mrs Rushton were disregarded, meaning that for many years she was provided with the very treatment she had taken great pains to refuse. It is particularly worrying that a GP surgery failed, either through a lack of understanding or a dereliction of duty, to take the necessary action to ensure a legally-binding Advance Decision (formerly known as a Living Will) was respected.

“As a result, Mrs Rushton’s family have had to endure not only the heartbreak of seeing a loved one become gravely ill with little hope of recovery, but a dispute over her care and treatment.

“Having supported more than 44,000 people to plan ahead for their future treatment and care, we know that people often choose to make an Advance Decision because they have strong feelings about the treatment they would not want in future, should they become unable to make or communicate such decisions. Many take great comfort and peace of mind from recording their wishes in such a legally binding way, rightly assuming that if they do become seriously unwell, difficult decisions will be taken out of the hands of their family members and doctors will be duty-bound by law to respect and follow their stated wishes.

“In research published last year, we revealed that callers to our Information Line reported GPs being hesitant, not confident or even unwilling to discuss or record their Advance Decisions, and that misunderstandings about the significance and role of Advance Decisions were common. Our experience shows that while patients feel ready and able to talk about death and dying, often healthcare professionals do not.

“If cases like Mrs Rushton’s are to be avoided in future, it is essential that GPs are supported to play their part in ensuring that their patients’ wishes for treatment and care can be properly discussed, recorded and followed. We recognise that GP practices are under immense pressure, so we want to offer our support and expertise to help improve practice.

“Free, specialist information on how to plan ahead is available to members of the public and healthcare professionals via Compassion in Dying’s nurse-led Information Line (0800 999 2434) and website.”


For further information or requests for interviews or comment, please contact Ellie Ball, Media & Campaigns Officer, at or 0207 479 7732

Notes to Editor:
Compassion in Dying’s report, Advance care planning in general practice – does policy match reality? Findings from a Freedom of Information request to Clinical Commissioning Groups in England, is available to download.

Advance Decision (to Refuse Treatment, also known as a ‘Living Will’): a legally binding document which allows an individual to record any medical treatments they do not want to be given in future, in case they later lack capacity and cannot make or communicate a decision for themselves.

About Compassion in Dying
We can help you prepare for the end of life. How to talk about it, plan for it, and record your wishes.
We help people through our free information line, publications and resources, and through our work with diverse communities. We specialise in supporting people to make Advance Decisions (‘Living Wills’) and to talk about their goals and priorities when living with a life-changing illness. Our free MyDecisions website helps people to record their wishes for care in a legally binding way.

Have any questions? Talk to us.
0800 999 2434

Is this page useful?

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.